A strong food safety system is more than a collection of individual programs. It depends on how well those programs work together. A vertical trace exercise provides a practical way to evaluate that connection by following a randomly selected product, lot, or production day through the complete record trail. Watch our SQF365 webinar presented by SCS Global Services exploring how a vertical trace exercise can provide a more complete view of your food safety system in action. Learn how random record selection can uncover gaps that traditional reviews may miss, demonstrate consistent execution across your operations, and help your facility prepare for evolving certification requirements.
3 Key Takeaways:
Follow the complete record trail: Instead of checking procedures separately, trace a single random lot or production day through every intersecting layer, such as receiving, sanitation, HACCP monitoring, labeling, and other programs.
Prevent cherry-picking of data: Randomly selecting the product and date removes subjectivity and forces the facility to demonstrate consistent, year-round operational execution instead of presenting handpicked "best-case" files.
Prepare for evolving standard requirements: Major certification schemes increasingly mandate vertical audit approaches during certification evaluations to test system alignment.
Tammie Van Buren: Okay, welcome. I have the top of the hour. We're going to get started. Thank you so much for joining us today. Uh we are so blessed to be uh sharing the screen with SCS consulting today and uh so yeah so we have our uh recording going. You will receive a copy of this recording after the webinar. Uh so no need to to ask or wonder. I'll just go ahead and throw that out there for you. Um but again thank you for joining us.
Tammie Van Buren: [0:43] Our topic today is called vertical trace connecting the dots across your uh food safety system. So, uh I'm going to put that antitrust statement up there anytime that we get um potential competitors uh together uh where we could start discussing um different topics that might uh cross over into violation of antitrust law. uh we always uh share this uh statement and so I'm putting that up on the screen uh for you guys. You all can take a a quick read of it. We are more than happy to provide you with a copy. Uh you can reach out to us uh if you would like uh to get a copy of that.
Tammie Van Buren: [1:25] We're always happy to share that. We're not going to talk about price fixing, market shares, boycotss, anything like that. Today we're talking about food safety and that is a topic that we are always uh able to discuss uh without uh violating any antitrust. If the conversation is heading into a a area that's uncomfortable um that you think may uh be questionable, please reach out to us and um we will uh also speak up if the same thing occurs. Um but I don't think it's going to be a problem today. We're because we're going to talk about vertical auditing.
Tammie Van Buren: [2:02] So, the two uh speakers today uh myself, I'm the senior compliance manager here at SQFI. I've been here gosh, it's going to be seven years next week. Heena, can you believe it? Seven years.
Heena Patel: [2:16] You were here when I first started. So, I know we go way back. Thank you, Tammie.
Tammie Van Buren: [2:22] Um I don't get to work with Heena often anymore because she's moved into the uh consulting side of things for SCS, uh one of our certification bodies. So, it was a a great treat for me to be able to uh work with Heena today because it's been a few years since we've been able to do that. I'm going to uh introduce Heena uh Patel. She is the director of consulting and technical services at SCS Consulting. And uh just a little bit of background uh she has over 25 years uh of specialized experience in quality food safety and regulatory compliance. Um she is a food safety expert and uh as I said senior consultant and director uh
Tammie Van Buren: [3:06] at SCS consulting services. Uh she has spent nearly two decades of conducting audits uh and building GFSI food safety programs from the ground up. Uh she was an auditor of the year with us. What I mean how long ago was that Heena? That
Heena Patel: [3:23] was pre my time I think. So do you Yeah, it was 2015. 2015 that was
Tammie Van Buren: [3:30] 2015. I think that was probably my first SQF conference as a um as a SQF practitioner. Uh so glad um that you gave us many years of uh auditing uh with SQF. Um she in her current role she provides expert consulting on manufacturing and farm operations. Um and she does some other things besides SQF. Um she has a long list. She also maintains certifications in ISO 901 as well as ISO7065. Thank you Heena for joining us today um to talk about this topic that I know is on everybody's mind uh because it's it's
Tammie Van Buren: [4:12] new for edition 10. So let's uh let's just jump in. uh we did come up with three key takeaways for uh today's webinar. One is make sure you complete that record trail. So the entire uh uh trail of records. So please uh keep that in mind. We've got some examples there. We're going to cover some examples during this webinar. Um random selection, right? Remember, we're not going to cherrypick the data. We have a method to the madness on how we're going to select um our site and it is rand or not our site our uh product and it is
Tammie Van Buren: [4:49] random. And then the third key takeaway is just be prepared because SQFI uh as well as maybe some of the other programs are going to require vertical auditing uh for uh their next um version of uh the standard. So, uh, yeah. So, hopefully, and we're going to review these key takeaways at the end, uh, to see if we covered all of that information. If not, please feel free to ask questions in the chat. Heena and I are just having a conversation here today. And if you have a question on a particular slide, please, please share in the chat what your question is, and we'll try to get that answered uh, as soon as possible. There will be a Q&A at
Tammie Van Buren: [5:31] the very end in case you think of something after the fact. and uh we will hang around and answer a few questions at the very end. So looking at Edition 10, the SQF code requirement uh is found in part a uh 211. It says the auditor will conduct a processbased audit uh using a vertical audit approach. Um it talks about tracing back through the manufacturing process. It will form the basis for all the records that they're going to pull. Um and uh they're going to look at a lot of different records.
Tammie Van Buren: [6:07] So we've got um what you may be accustomed to under Edition 9, which is that checklist audit. Uh starts at 2.1 uses the checklist as a questionnaire. I'm sure Heena remembers her many days of SQF auditing. You know, you had your checklist and basically you just went down the list and you asked questions. And so, uh, edition 10's going to be a little bit different of a format. Um, we're going to encourage our auditors to start at a logical place. I don't know. For me, Heena, logical point might be the food safety plan. Yes.
Heena Patel: [6:45] You know, yeah, I totally agree. Yes.
Tammie Van Buren: [6:47] Yeah. Grab that flowchart and that's probably where we're going to start. Um, for most auditors, um, you're going to use, uh, auditors are going to use the check list more as a guide for covering the entire code rather than a checklist for asking questions. And so, um, it's going to be different for sure. Um, but hopefully it's going to be more meaningful as far as helping sites see the connection, um, between all of the different programs um, that they're overseeing. So, um, are you excited about it, Heena? I, you know, I know you're more on the consulting side these days, but you know, are you are your
Tammie Van Buren: [7:28] clients excited about it or are they worried, you know, because it's different? Well, no, that they're excited about it.
Heena Patel: [7:36] I mean, they're familiar with the traceability program. So, you know, vertical audit approach is slightly different for them. But then I'm working very closely with them, you know, and kind of coaching them how to conduct a vertical audit. Yeah. Oh yeahroach.
Tammie Van Buren: [7:50] Yeah, I'm very excited. I I I can't wait to uh start doing Edition 10 audits so I can get some feedback to see um you know where the questions are or um how much people enjoy this type of audit versus a checklist. So um we're going to start off with a poll question. So um this was something uh Heena had put in. So you'll see on your screen, how familiar are you with vertical audits? So very much so. Maybe you've been doing it for a while in your own internal audit program. Um are you somewhat familiar with it? You've kind of heard a little bit about it maybe as we've been preparing for Edition 10 or is it possibly new to you completely?
Tammie Van Buren: [8:38] Um we're going to give you time to vote. I see votes coming in. So that's uh actually you all were on it. I think everybody's voted already. People are prepared to uh be interactive. So, we've got about 10% that said very much so, very familiar with it. About 62% that um said h somewhat. I know a little bit. And then uh we've got about a third that said it's it's really new to me. Uh so hopefully
Tammie Van Buren: [9:09] uh you can get all your questions answered today. Uh we already have a question in the chat. How exciting is a vertical audit also a good way to conduct internal audits? What do you think Heena?
Heena Patel: [9:23] Yes, I mean vertical audit is part of an internal audit. So obviously you know your responsibility is to make sure that you understand the whole process right from point A to point Z. So yes definitely you should be doing vertical exercise during the internal audit and just check your system out and see if there are any gaps or not and then work towards it. I you know I
Tammie Van Buren: [9:46] think um doing your internal audit now to Edition 10 and using that vertical audit approach where you're pulling those records uh as it relates I think it will um be a good exercise uh to be used as a gap assessment uh for their Edition 10 external audit. Um and then uh Desiree asked will this replace the process of giving specific dates for record review? uh Desiree. Uh you know, I'm not going to say that it will replace all of it. Um because there may be situations depending on the product and the lot number that's uh pulled that it may not touch every single program. I
Tammie Van Buren: [10:29] mean, one program Hen and I were talking about last week was the um the some of the label claims. So, as a part of the legislative requirement to 41 in the code, uh we we look at our auditors look at label claims. And so, if you don't pull a product that has a certain label claim, there could be additional requirements that um additional uh production days or lot codes, part numbers uh that the auditor may want to see. So, um let's go ahead and jump in. We've got another question, but um uh we're I think we've kind of already touched on that. Um but Heena, go ahead and walk us through. So, Edition nine,
Tammie Van Buren: [11:12] what are we currently doing as far as a a a trace exercise?
Heena Patel: [11:17] Yeah, thank you, Tammie. So, this is like a quick check on traceability exercise. As you can see, the process flow. This slide kind of outlines a streamline rapid response trace exercise to test basically raw mass uh balance data. uh for example the finished product is picked and the lot number of finished product is traced back to the raw materials and suppliers. So when a traceability exercise is conducted as you all know you must have done traceability exercise right? So the primary goal is to see if the site can reconcile production numbers quickly uh without getting bogged down in extensive
Heena Patel: [11:52] documentation reviews. So the primary focus is on percentage recovery where calculation is conducted on total amount of finished products made and finished products shipped out and how much the products have been left in the inventory and how much the products have been disposed of. And so under Edition 9 uh it's a practical test of how well the site can track ingredients and finished products through its supply chain. And that's covered under element 2.6.2 traceability section. And the site must demonstrate the ability to trace raw materials, primary packaging, any processing aids they have, any finished products towards customer and and backwards to supplier and records must
Heena Patel: [12:34] be maintained. So product can be traced one step forward and and one step back. So unlike full scale mock recalls that track every ingredient supplier and traceability exercise is typically completed in less than two hours to test immediate data availability and this type of exercise tends to give limited information. So an auditor will typically pick a product and a lot number and assign the site to conduct the traceability exercise or conducts the traceability exercise with the team. And in the next slide, we'll be covering Edition 10, you know, to to compare edition nine versus Edition 10.
Tammie Van Buren: [13:10] Yeah. And I like the fact that you mentioned the words mass balance. That's that's not terminology that's written into the code, but really that trace exercise uh as you cited 2.6.2, that really is what that is is a a a mass balance exercise. So you're looking solely on the quantities. So you're not necessarily pulling records or things. You're just looking, you know, as you said, just at the numbers that um align with that, you know, activity. So it truly is just a mass balance still required under Edition 10. So 2.6.2 is still there. you still have to do um
Tammie Van Buren: [13:51] your trace forward as Heena said to the finished um customers and the trace backwards as she mentioned uh with the raw ingredients. So that's still a requirement. Um but we're going to go on to the next slide and she's going to talk to you about Edition 10. So how does that expand? How does that trace you know now become a vertical audit?
Heena Patel: [14:15] All right. So vertical audit is required to be conducted over the course of the entire audit. So it's like a whole process, right? Reviewing from point A to point Z. Um and vertical audit approach it requires auditors to evaluate how all parts of the food safety system works together. It's just not traceability, right? It's focusing on the systems uh around a specific batch or production date of the particular product. So it's basically an evaluation method by tracing the product completely through every stage of the manufacturing process steps rather than reviewing documents in isolated silos.
Heena Patel: [14:51] Um the shift uh moves the focus beyond the paperwork alone by verifying whether the process controls are in place or not. So when conducting vertical audit pick the most complex hassle plan uh that has several process steps. Pick a product associated with the particular hassle plan and a product that has been already shipped out. Select a bill of leading and trace back from shipping of finished products to receiving of ingredients. Review all records associated with each process step in the process flow diagram. So the focus is on process flow diagram as well. Example receiving records right that starts the first step is receiving supply chain verification.
Heena Patel: [15:31] Then you move towards production records batch records. You look at CCPs, pre controls, product testing, product formulation, specifications and and the list can go on. So, uh in addition, interview workers who had completed the records, right? To see if they understand what what they actually doing, right? They understand the process, you know, in their areas of responsibility. At the same time, you can verify GMP practices while you are on the production flow, cross check the process flow and record keeping system as well and try to go during different shifts, right? to make sure that the process is consistent. So auditors may review processes such as product holds as well or customer returns by tracing
Heena Patel: [16:10] the products journey from receiving and production through quarantine, reprocessing and destruction. So that's the information I had on and there's a whole great list on on what to look at examples of records, right? CFAS and all the prerequisite programs uh lot numbers. Um yeah, all the records associated to each production process.
Tammie Van Buren: [16:33] Yeah. And you're going to by taking that process flow, you're going to hit all those major um process steps. Um and and we've got many of those records that are associated with that listed up there. Um there are probably some uh programs though that we may need to consider. Uh things like um food fraud for example. So, you probably don't have a record related to a specific lot for food fraud, but you certainly could touch something like that as you're going back through those ingredients, looking at
Tammie Van Buren: [17:14] things um that may be uh listed on the food fraud vulnerability uh assessment. So, in that case, you may get into some records that are not lot specific, but maybe product. So, um I like the idea that you said suggested, you know, uh getting a food safety plan, um that's very complex and so that you can really look through um a a greater uh variety of processes and procedures uh that uh would be impacting that particular product. Um so, we've got a couple more questions in the chat here.
Tammie Van Buren: [17:53] So, how often should we conduct vertical audits or should all our internal audits be done with a vertical audit? What do you think, Kina? Which you know what what what would best prepare a site for their addition to an audit?
Heena Patel: [18:10] Right. So, typically companies do annual um vertical exercises. So, I would highly recommend to kind of do it more than once and yes try to do it during insulin audit as well. uh you know just to cover the the traceability and you know the whole vertical audit approach. So it is up to the site and if you find many gaps in the system if you find gaps uh in the record keeping as well then do as many as you want just to make sure that you close those gaps. So there is no like hard rule I mean minimum is annually but you can always uh focus more in some other areas where you think that that needs to be improved.
Tammie Van Buren: [18:49] Yeah absolutely. um SQF doesn't uh require that you use a vertical audit as a part of your internal audit. Um but that will help to prepare you for your external audit. Um because that is the way that the that auditor will be doing it. So uh I agree with Heena. You know it says annual on your internal audit or on your trace exercise. Um but you should just keep keep doing it. you know, if you find issues, then you're going to want to fix those and do it again and and um continue to do it. Uh we've mentioned already uh several times when
Tammie Van Buren: [19:29] we were going to um do it uh as far as hitting different products, different shifts, uh different uh uh areas of the plant. So, uh or the facility. So, uh do it as many times as you need to. It doesn't have to always align uh with an internal audit. You could, you know, you could do your trace exercise separately. You could do your vertical audit separately. Uh so just do it as many times as you need to do it um to make sure that um that it's understood and that you're uh filling all those gaps. So um uh the next statement is the vertical audit. Oh, somebody posted a question and my thing scrolled. Okay.
Tammie Van Buren: [20:13] Okay, the vertical audit for SQF is going into more detail of what steps are needed to verify and document an item that has been shipped. What about raw materials that are received? Well, that's the great part about this vertical audit exercise because you're you're using that shipping process to select the product and the lot code, but eventually over the course of the entire uh audit, you're going to be working back to that receiving as well. So hold that thought because we have um uh [clears throat] Heena got uh brought us an example a real life example we're going to discuss on the next slide. Uh so hopefully that will uh help you to uh
Tammie Van Buren: [20:55] see that. Uh next question is will auditors from the certifying body still be required to provide or reference objective evidence for each element of this code as before using the checklist? you mentioned the code acts more of a guide but a traditional checklist is still provided by SQFI on the website. So yes and and so we call it a checklist um but honestly what we put on the um website that we call a checklist it's not really a checklist it's a copy of our code so element byelement the code
Tammie Van Buren: [21:27] is there again to be used as a guide to make sure um that you are covering everything within your internal audit. I will say I get to sometimes witness SQF auditors and the best uh audit I ever witnessed, I never even saw the SQF code checklist uh until the last day of the audit. And literally the auditor what he did was a process audit. The very first document he asked for and this was two years ago during edition 9. So we already have some auditors that are using a process audit. uh the first document he did ask for was the food
Tammie Van Buren: [22:07] safety plan and that's where he started and he started uh looking at audit trails and so it really was a masterpiece you know to watch how all those pieces were audited as a process audit not a checklist audit and as I mentioned he didn't bring out the checklist till the last day of the audit and then he used it to go down through there and say oh wait we haven't talked about food defense yet let's talk about food defense So, it really was used as a a checklist in the sense of the term I'm checking to make sure uh that I covered everything rather than a you know uh
Tammie Van Buren: [22:46] list of questions to ask because that's not really what the checklist is. It's it's actually the code that we've just put in an Excel format for you all uh to use uh with your internal audits. So, um, Justine said we can ignore the [laughter] her question, but you know what? Some of the other people may have the exact same question. So, we don't we don't mind uh asking uh answering uh all the questions. Uh we've got uh in my experience over the past 13 years, many of our uh SQF auditors have had our
Tammie Van Buren: [23:19] facilities use this method of vertical auditing. Yeah. So, as I said, we do have some auditors that already using it. Uh it is very helpful to see how the systems work together and um I I agree with you Jason it does help you understand where those gaps are. So you would recommend doing one with your team at least annually. Yay. Thank you Jason for supporting um that and making that uh uh comment because it um it's always helpful when we hear from other sites. Uh I don't know about you, Heena, but I know um for me it's always beneficial to hear other people's point of views uh
Tammie Van Buren: [23:59] because uh you know sometimes it's not all about just what Tammie thinks or what the auditor thinks but um but hearing what other people are doing uh I think is a a great benefit.
Heena Patel: [24:14] Mhm. Yeah, that's great because I had witnessed myself when I was witnessing one of the auditors and he did the vertical audit like that's this was 10 years ago. I'm like, "Wow, this is great." You know, we had we had that experience of and and you know, it just made the audit more efficient rather than looking at lots of hundreds of records. You just pick one product and then you just follow the process flow and then look at all the records applicable to those process steps. It kind of streamline streamlines the whole audit process.
Tammie Van Buren: [24:43] Absolutely. Um, you know, and Justine, yeah, it's a guideline. So, it's it's that checklist in terms of you're just checking to make sure you've covered everything. So, uh, so uh so glad that that's the way you all are using that instead of conducting uh that checklist audit. And I, you know, I'm glad to hear that, you know, we've had auditors that have been doing that for quite some time. Uh, and one of the questions we always get, Heena, since you, um, brought it up and you said that it makes the audit more efficient. Uh, we've had people question, does doing a process audit take more time than doing a
Tammie Van Buren: [25:23] checklist audit or does it just seem that way? Because maybe we're not used to that methodicated
Heena Patel: [25:32] process. I mean, once you kind of start doing it, you'll be you have the records, right? So uh just look at the record that's applicable to that particular hassa plan and every year just uh use also a different product. So don't stick to one product every year. Right? Because the whole intention is to make sure that you are ready when the audit comes in. Right? Audit will pick up the product on a random basis. So this site must be ready applicable to all of the HASSA plans and make sure that you know they have all the records in place that can apply to the vertical exercise and traceability as well and also interview people who completes the records, right? So it's it's like a whole process uh when when doing production
Heena Patel: [26:12] inspections, right? Cross check all the records, cross check the process flow and and uh and interview with the people so they understand, you know, just to cross check if they understand or not, right? Those processes.
Tammie Van Buren: [26:25] Yeah. All right. Well, let's go on to our uh scenario. So, Heena, I'll let you walk us through that. What have we got here? Uh and then we'll just talk about some of the records and how we would go about doing that uh vertical audit processbased audit.
Heena Patel: [26:42] Okay, great. Thank you, Tammie. So this is a great scenario where a QA manager conducted a vertical audit on October 14, 2026 on a single batch or yogurt with a lot number with 502 that had many ingredients. Products were packed online 426 and shipped out already. So typically vertical traceability is slicing the product vertically and seeing layers of ingredients and tracing one of the ingredients at and any inputs in the finished product and and vice versa. So in this case I would pick a pick pick an allergen uh ingredient and conduct a vertical exercise by cross-checking each process step in the flow diagram making sure records are in
Heena Patel: [27:25] place making direct observations on the flow verifying the process steps verifying employee practices and how they're monitoring CCPs or primitive controls and other areas and also verify alleged management program label reviews for compliant GMPs and other practices. So, it is like a one-stop shop, right? You just look at all the information while you're on the production floor. This is all about verification and and and and real time information, real time records, right? We are doing a vertical audit.
Tammie Van Buren: [27:56] Exactly. So, um in in your scenario here, you've listed a few of the ingredients. Uh and and to go along with one of the questions that we had asked in the chat, how do you get back to in a vertical audit? How do you get back um to talking about the receiving of ingredients? So, we're looking at in this case milk, strawberry puree, peach puree. This sounds really good. I'm not going to lie. I could probably go for uh one of those [laughter] yogurts about now. Pistachio nuts and some other minor minor ingredients packed in a plastic cup. So, um, are you going to pick, you know, as an auditor,
Tammie Van Buren: [28:38] and I know you've got lots of auditing experience, are you going to pick, you know, the main ingredient or, you know, I know sometimes we might shy away from doing the big ingredient? Uh, but would we start with milk or would we pick something else? What what what strategy can you suggest to sites? Where should they head?
Heena Patel: [28:59] could probably pick the primary uh ingredient saying in this case will be milk and then um trace it forward and then uh connect it to the finished product and if things are going smoothly you know I would probably pick couple of other ingredients and see where they are you know in the journey of vertical audit. So it just depends how the how the exercise is going on.
Tammie Van Buren: [29:23] Yeah. No, I I mean I came from bakery and ph the thought of doing flour as an ingredient was always scary. Uh but uh yeah, we we should dive into those. We shouldn't shy away from the big ingredient that's used across multiple platforms and products and uh could be something stored in like tankers or silos and um that that's where you look at your you know your real your program and it is it really working. Uh so in
Heena Patel: [29:56] the chat somebody said would it be best to look at the ingredient with the highest risk assessment? What do you think about that Heena? Yes, I would pick, you know, an allergen product, right? So, at the same time, I can verify the allergen program and label verification as well. So, yeah, I mean, that's that's a really good point.
Tammie Van Buren: [30:14] Yeah. And somebody else suggested picking the the allergen ingredients, the pistachio or the milk, uh, due to it being an allergen. So, uh, we've got coming from dairy, it would make sense to look at the main ingredient, but it has a very different supply chain than say jalapeno peppers. Yeah, that's a that's a big difference between milk and uh, jalapeno peppers. So, uh, it would uh, give you a different supply chain, a different look at uh, how those ingredients are received, how they're handled. Um, you get into, I mean, even how they're shipped, they come in differently, right? Milk comes in in a
Tammie Van Buren: [30:53] tanker and uh jalapenos come in in a truck. So, um very different in how they've uh how they've been handled. Milk has probably been processed before. Jalapenos may be coming essentially straight from the field, straight from the uh farm through the pack house. Um how would you look at those things differently, Heena?
Heena Patel: [31:19] Yeah, I mean these are some pretty good questions. So yeah, obviously primary packaging needs to be traced as well, right? It's just not the product. So anything that comes in contact with the with the product also needs to be traced. But going back to your question, Tammie, yeah, I mean if if the product look at the process flow and see how complex it is. So rather than just picking one product, say for example, this this product had uh jalapeno and it some other produce item in it, you know, in the yogurt. So I would probably end up picking two ingredients just to verify the process. I mean there is no straight rule like you know pulling just
Heena Patel: [31:57] just one ingredient. So you just have to evaluate the ingredients as well. Yeah. High risk, low risk and all that and then and then pick up that hassa plan.
Tammie Van Buren: [32:08] Yeah. And in this scenario, I mean strawberry puree, peach puree very well could come from the same supplier. So you probably wouldn't do both of those. Um, but you know that is a potential you you might pick one of those. Uh, talked about the pistachio nuts. Um, but let's get into packaging. So, how about that plastic cup or that lid that's going to go on there or even that film that's going to cover the top of that yogurt cup before the lid goes on? Um, what what do you think about there? And, uh, would you look at one piece of the packaging? Would you, you know, consider
Tammie Van Buren: [32:49] looking at the film? Uh, how would you handle packaging?
Heena Patel: [32:53] I would look at all the packaging, primary packaging material, the cup, the lid. uh you know I mean I would not just pick one if if I if I was doing the audit you know and I think during this vertical audit approach that I I think
Tammie Van Buren: [33:10] it is going to give us a lot more opportunity to look at things like the packaging that maybe we didn't think about before. Um I've witnessed auditors where they pulled ingredients but sometimes we do forget about that packaging uh and how important it is uh to make sure we include that in the audit. Right. Yeah. So, great questions. Keep them coming in. We are uh you know looking uh forward to being able to answer all your questions today about vertical audit. Um but um what about those programs? Uh we've talked a little bit about one of
Tammie Van Buren: [33:46] the things you mentioned was label verification. So obviously we've got label verification that takes place at the production line where we say yes we have the right label that we're matching to the right product. Um but what about that label verification program that h happens before it even makes its way to the line. So um this vertical approach is going to see that how did that label get verified to begin with? And I know Heena, you and I talked, we've talked about those label claims and things that would fall under the regulatory requirements,
Tammie Van Buren: [34:25] but you know, how are we going to, you know, look at um that process of label verification uh for um our our labels. Uh so you know maybe you can share some insight into some best practices um that you've seen where uh making sure that those labels are being checked before they're ever approved uh to be uh you know produced. What are some of the things that you've seen with some sites um that they're doing for label verification that uh may be of interest to our audience today?
Heena Patel: [35:04] Right. So like at the receiving step I've seen uh the receivers will take a look at the label and they will verify the labels. Obviously QA will also will have the same responsibility as well and the finish and the label uh specifications also provided at the receiving point. So they can cross check the labels and then once it's approved then the labels are taken to the storage area and if it's not approved then obviously the labels are rejected right there and there. So that's kind of a pre-check right before the labels are carried over all the way to the production uh for the finished product.
Heena Patel: [35:42] So that's that's a really good step that you would probably want to review labels as well before it ends up in the in the in in the production area.
Tammie Van Buren: [35:53] Yeah. Because by the time it gets to the production area, that's, you know, if the label's not correct to begin with, then um we don't even want to see that in the production area, right? Um so one thing we haven't touched on today um how can we incorporate change management that's a big thing now for Edition 10 uh so it it has its own separate clause. So how can we incorporate change management into um looking at our vertical audit? Um for me labels was one of those. How often do we see labels that change? Um, ingredients that change. So, is there
Tammie Van Buren: [36:38] something else, Heena, that we could, um, you know, give our audience today a suggestion on don't forget this um when you're looking at, um, that vertical audit,
Heena Patel: [36:51] right? Formulation changes. uh you know so it's always good to connect with R&D team and make sure that there's effective communication uh among the team right from R&D to QA and then to production and if formulation changes then obviously the label is going to change so change management basically requires a formal approval process right it's just not done by one person there must be several people signing off on the change management plan why changes are happening reasons behind it and then communicating those changes to to production employees to QA team and rest of the other team on those particular changes. So yeah and document control I
Heena Patel: [37:32] know that happens quite a bit has a plan changes as well. So communication needs to be there, approval process needs to be there. It should not be just done by a square practitioner or by the QA team, right? Because you have a food safety team that has representatives from different departments and they need to understand why changes are getting made, right? So communication is really important and so please come up with a comprehensive uh change management policy and and work towards the communication plan as well on any changes otherwise there'll be lots of gaps found you know during the audit or or during production process as well.
Tammie Van Buren: [38:07] Yeah absolutely. So yeah, so somebody did say for label verification, do we start from formulation? And I would think that's a yes. You know, going back I'm glad you mentioned formula. So um going back to that formulation to make sure that that label does match. So as well as another thing we haven't I mean you mentioned I think on the list was specification. So um you know pulling that you know product spec uh to make sure that that also matches. So all of that works together. So I'm enjoying this conversation cuz we're we're kind of listening how everything you know flows together and uh leads you during
Tammie Van Buren: [38:49] that vertical audit from from here to over here as well. So um now we've got I think a tough question in the um chat here. Food safety culture has some new requirements also. How will that be included in the vertical audit?
Heena Patel: [39:06] Oh, that's a tough one. [laughter] Well, you'll have to do food safety um culture assessment, right? Come up with a plan and and again, it's all about communication and making people feel part of the team. Uh empower them in in the areas of responsibility. uh so that you know there'll be less gaps found uh during inspections or during audits or in a day-to-day function. Yeah.
Tammie Van Buren: [39:33] Um one of the things that for me for food safety culture uh one of the things that I think people are going to miss is uh in the current food safety culture uh requirement under Edition 9. It talks about uh senior uh site leadership uh leading that food safety culture. Uh in Edition 10 uh GFSI updated their requirements that says and so we did as well updated SQF where it says there has to be a demonstraable commitment.
Tammie Van Buren: [40:11] And I looked that word up just so I could be clear on what demonstrable meant. um commitment from all employees. And so that's new for edition 10. And I just think some people are going to miss that. So go back and read 2.1.1.2 to if you haven't um and and pay close attention to where it's talking about that demonstrable commitment because you could as you're going through your vertical audit and you're identifying different auditors I'm sorry not different auditors but different operators uh CCP operators uh process operators that were involved in that process receiving and shipping operators
Tammie Van Buren: [40:51] um you could um ask for you know how how does that person how did they demonst demonstrate a commitment to food safety culture. And so I would seek out some of those employees uh that are involved in that vertical audit um whose names keep coming up uh to find out how they are u meeting that part of the food safety culture uh requirement because that is new for Edition 10 and I'm afraid that some people are going to miss that. So uh let's see uh under Edition 10 2.1.2.2 too. Uh, management must be updated at least monthly on CCP deviations, kappas, audit results,
Tammie Van Buren: [41:32] complaints. If senior management is on site daily and is copied on every food safety email, does that count as the monthly update or does the auditor expect a separate monthly record such as a summary report or meeting minutes that covers all four topics? So, um, what do you think, Kina? What's I mean I know I have my thoughts on that but what do you think is is that enough if there's emails that pass back and forth and you know make the rounds is that enough to meet that requirement for that monthly update?
Heena Patel: [42:04] uh I don't think so because the intention of having monthly meeting is to have open communication right between the sen management and other managers from the department right so uh summarizing the information and and putting it in front of sen management is very important so that the communication is open and discussions can happen you know during the monthly meeting uh and and the requirement is there has to
Tammie Van Buren: [42:28] be a response so it's it's communication is not that one one way ticket. So, you know, Kim's just not feeding Heena all this information, but Heena actually has to respond and there has to be action items that come out of that. So, um yeah. So, no, that's a great question. But, um I you know, I'm kind of with you. I like seeing that and we see it with sites. Sites do try to pull all this different stuff to demonstrate that they are doing it. And I and I'm not doubting that they're doing it. Um, but
Tammie Van Buren: [43:04] having that monthly update where it's demonstrating that, you know, we've pulled all that information together that we talk about every day and I know you talk about it every day, but having that I you like the word summary that you use. Um, I used to do that when I was a practitioner. We would have a weekly meeting and at the end of the month I would summarize everything we talked about during that weekly meeting and I would sit down with the plant manager and we would say oh we talked about this and here's our action items and we would sign off on that summary. So lots of different ways to do it. Um but it's it's about being able to demonstrate that it's happening uh
Tammie Van Buren: [43:46] completely. So um and that's where a lot of people will miss that responsiveness
Heena Patel: [43:52] and closing that communication gap. Um yeah and then also monthly meetings have happen every month right so relying on email communications probably you'll be looking for the emails right during the meetings. are recapping all the information and then doing a follow-up. That's that's that's another thing that needs to get conducted, right? Because senior management uh would like to know what's happening uh on the production floor would like to know you know whether the program is working or not and how much support the team is asking from them. So there has to be very clear open communication and follow-up is really important because you might have one monthly meeting and there are some like eight or nine items
Heena Patel: [44:31] they're still open then when the next monthly meeting comes then the the goal is to complete all those action items so that you can move forward with with uh with any other issues that that that might probably come up you know between between different months. So uh yeah recapping the information and having open communication is very important.
Tammie Van Buren: [44:52] Yeah. No, that's a great point. Uh, somebody said, "I understand emails are not enough, but my monthly management meetings with responses from department will be enough." Uh, so I can't say yes or no because I haven't seen I haven't seen your monthly meetings. Um, but, uh, you know, having that communication and those responses, those that's really the the key part to there. um is having the the monthly meetings, the responses, and as Heena mentioned, that followup to make sure those action items are being closed and they're not just, you know, left out there to to wander aimlessly. Um, okay. So, uh, we also have a question about how do we integrate the food safety objectives into our vertical audit?
Tammie Van Buren: [45:44] That one might be a tough one. That might be one that you say at the end of the day, you know what? I didn't get to that in my vertical audit. I didn't cross that path. So, that may be one that you have to specifically as a part of your internal audit or that the auditor will reach out specifically and and look uh at the food safety objectives because you may not cross the path of uh your food safety objectives in your vertical audit. So, what what what are your thoughts? Heena.
Heena Patel: [46:16] Yeah. So the object objective is typically to produce safe product, right? Then you're going to come up with KPIs, right? To support your objective, key performance indicators. So if your KPI is uh to reduce number of complaints, okay, every year, every month. Um so you will look at that particular product and see if there have been any complaints associated with that product. Right? your your your KPI will probably be uh I don't want to have any recall. So that's an overarching information, right? So you can look at that particular product uh when you're doing the vertical exercise and see uh if the product has been implicated with
Heena Patel: [46:56] any recalls or not. I mean it could be sanitation. I mean you can have as many KPIs as possible. And so try to tie it as you are looking at each and every process step try to tie in just just have have at the back of your mind whether this process has actually like recalls or environmental monitoring has actually affected this product or not right. So it all depends on your KPIs.
Tammie Van Buren: [47:21] I thank you. It all depends. So that's a that's a answer we like to say sometimes is it depends and and I think this is one of those opportunities where we would say uh it depends. Um so this question is what do you think about a company having preventive controls instead of CCP? So this is a frequently asked question uh of SQF. Uh we uh get asked um in relation to a PCQI or
Tammie Van Buren: [47:55] versus a HASSUP training or uh a PC plan versus a HASSUP plan. And just to clarify that the code and this is currently under Edition 9 as well as Edition 10. This has not changed. Uh if you are certified to SQF uh you are required to have a HASSUP a food safety plan that meets the 12 steps of HASSUP. That is a requirement. You cannot substitute a PC plan. Uh the only code currently under edition 9 that you can have a PC plan and not a Hasset plan is a storage and distribution. However, for Edition 10, GFSI added the requirement back that you do have to have a a food safety plan for storage
Tammie Van Buren: [48:44] and distribution based on HASSUP and that was eliminated under Edition 9. So hopefully uh the storage and distribution people that are listening, that was that's a key change for storage and distribution Edition 10 is we're adding back in that um requirement that your food safety plan meets uh the 12 steps of HASSUP. So you have to have a food safety plan meeting the 12 steps of HASSUP. If you are held under FISMA, uh then you are also required to have a food safety plan uh that meets the PCs or the preventive controls. Uh so it's
Tammie Van Buren: [49:24] about having the plan. It's not whether you have a PC or CCP. They're not either or because if you look at the definition of preventive controls versus CCPs, they are different. So please look at the definition of a PC versus a CCP. I don't know about you, Heena, but I typically see sites that combine those into one food safety plan. So, um, yeah, definitely. Yeah.
Heena Patel: [49:51] I' I've seen that as well. And in the PCQI version two training, they have some great examples of combined uh PC plan and CCP plan. I mean you don't have to have separate ones because sometimes in your house plan you might have couple of CCPs and you might probably want to control a sanitation program through primitive controls. Uh you can use another prerequisite program uh like allergen management as well as a primitive control. It doesn't have to be a CCP and then the supply chain right incoming can printive control where you're going to look at third party audit reports or CFAs and do risk assessment of the raw materials. So there's no like hard co answer like okay
Heena Patel: [50:30] this one yeah which which step should be a PC or critical control point you just have to do risk assessment and then use if you want to minimize CCPS then use per controls you know I mean use prerect program to control uh the process and practices.
Tammie Van Buren: [50:47] Yeah we've got someone that posted that having a combined uh plan has been a great improvement for their sites. That's good to hear. I came from a facility we had a combined plan. So, uh we had both CCPs and PCs. Um and they were not the same. Uh they were um definitely different. So, um again, I encourage people look at the definition of what is a CCP versus what's a PC. And I think you will see that they are different. They could be the same in some cases. Some of your process preventive controls might be the same as a CCP, but not always. and Heena gave
Tammie Van Buren: [51:25] some great examples on some of those PCs that would not be a CCP. And so, uh, yeah. So, definitely, uh, and just in case anybody's wondering out there, Heena mentioned PCQI version two training. Uh, we do accept that and say that that meets the definition of HASSIP training, uh, as found in our glossery. Uh, version one did not. uh but version two did add in uh more focus on uh including the 12 steps of HASSUP as a part of that training. So uh we do uh know that that that training will cover the 12 steps of
Tammie Van Buren: [52:05] HASSUP as required by our definition. So all right, as we come to the end of our webinar, here's our key takeaways again. So we're going to put these back up on the screen. Hopefully we can kind of check all these off and say that we uh we met those. So completing that record trail. So we talked about a lot of records today, right Heena? So start to finish shipping back to receiving suppliers, we talked about food fraud, uh we talked about change management, uh so lot of records. Make sure that you cover all of those um and look at those as a part of that vertical audit. uh the random selection. So again, don't take
Tammie Van Buren: [52:46] the easy way out. Don't cherry pick. You know, I'm gonna take the easy product. I I you know, I'm gonna pick a lot that I only made a hundred cases of so that I can, you know, uh limit the amount of uh records that we're looking at. You know, challenge yourself. You know, don't, you know, randomly select, but also don't select something that's too easy on you. Okay. Um and then be prepared because your your Edition 10 audit is going to be uh conducted as a vertical audit and they the auditor will select a product that is already shipped uh a product and
Tammie Van Buren: [53:24] a lot code and they will uh look at all the records associated uh from finish back to start uh on on that particular product and lot code. So, um, any more questions? Feel free, uh, to put in the chat. Um, this is your last opportunity before we sign off. Any parting thoughts, Heena, as we go. Thank you so much for being here. It was such fun for me to get to hang out with you the last few weeks prepared.
Heena Patel: [53:57] Thank you, Tammie. It was a good opportunity for me to coordinate with SUFF and give this webinar together. I think it was very informative and I hope everyone will take information from this webinar and conduct a a vertical audit exercise and and cross check the system.
Tammie Van Buren: [54:16] Yeah, absolutely. So, thank you all. Um here is uh SQFI's contact information. Uh Heena, if you want to put in the chat your contact information, maybe your email, um then uh if people have any follow-up questions for you, uh they can feel free to uh reach out to you uh directly. Oh, okay. Great. Oh, Coup said Heena's email will be included in our follow-up email tomorrow. Coup is on it. He [laughter] So, great. Well, it's Yeah, so Oh, yeah. And Heena put it in there. So, in the chat there, um, we do have a
Tammie Van Buren: [54:54] question. I have an SQF audit happening on February 27th. Uh, will this be already on version 10? I'm going to say, Juan, probably. Uh, we are into our last u few weeks of benchmarking. Uh, so we are hoping that that benchmarking will be completed uh within the next uh few weeks. And so, uh, only if GFSI is delayed will that delay, uh, that February, uh, well, our January, uh, planned implementation date. Uh, so, uh, yeah. So, plan for Edition 10. There
Tammie Van Buren: [55:34] really is only one thing that if you um change over to Edition 10 that you need to make sure that you continue to do and that would be your annual proficiency testing for any of your food safety um testing. Just make sure you do have that annually done because that is the requirement under Edition 9. We removed the word annual for Edition 10. So, um, so just make sure you still have that and you should be fine even if you've already got Edition 10 implemented. Uh, somebody said, "Is there a time limit limit to complete a vertical trace during an audit?" Uh, no, because SQF doesn't doesn't give you a time limit.
Tammie Van Buren: [56:13] Typically, sites will set up uh time limits, but the vertical audit will take place across the entire audit. Uh, a trace exercise, you know, is a piece of that. And so that would be focused on looking at the traceability of the product. Uh so uh but we do not put time limits on trace exercises. We we never have. So you might have customer requirements out there. Make sure you check those. Uh sometimes customers do require a specific time limit on a traceability exercise. Um but uh SQF does not uh have that requirement. So
Tammie Van Buren: [56:52] again, thank you all so much and uh yeah, join us for our next one. We have another webinar coming up in a couple of weeks. Uh so please um uh take a look at that uh and join us. Uh we do have one last question I'm going to ask real quick just because we are um down at the end. For the proficiency testing, is it required to have these from thirdparty um labs? So, we do not say that your proficiency testing has to be conducted by a third-party lab. However, I will say that with the caveat that the ones that I've seen that are not done by third party lab typically have not met the requirement of proficiency testing.
Tammie Van Buren: [57:36] So, proficiency testing is comparing your lab with other labs. And so typically you will do that via a third-party um proficiency testing program. Uh but in some cases uh I sites can uh create their own but you still are not relieved from having to do that testing comparing yourself to other labs. So, um I'm not saying that you can't find a way to do that. Um because it is possible, uh but um I just don't see sites very often. Okay. Um and uh the comment on the water. Um I
Tammie Van Buren: [58:22] I'm not sure about proficiency testing for storage and distribution. Uh, I would have to look up the code um just because uh I don't I don't know off the top of my head. But uh just take a look at that um to see if it's there. If it's not there, then you hey, you don't have to [clears throat] worry about it, right? All right. Well, thank you all so much for joining us today. Um it was a pleasure and uh we hope to see you uh soon at the next one. Thank you all so much.
This webinar is the third of a four-part series about FSMA Rule 204 and provides information about FDA food traceability tools and resources, along with steps to following a traceability plan.
When working with a supply chain that is constantly changing, it is essential to have critical risk mitigation strategies to protect your food safety culture.
Privacy Policy |
Terms of Use
251 18th Street S., Suite 1200 Arlington, VA 22202 | Phone: (202) 220-0635
© SQFI. All Rights Reserved.
Web Design & Development by Matrix Group International, Inc.